The Short Version
Here's the deal: if belt tracking is your top priority and door access isn't, GymDesk has you covered. But if real-time door access control tied to billing is crucial for your gym, ManageMemberships has the edge. For those needing both, ManageMemberships is developing belt tracking, while GymDesk's door access is a $100/month add-on.
What GymDesk Does Better
GymDesk excels in belt/rank tracking. This is their bread and butter with features like curriculum management, grading, and promotions—ideal for martial arts schools. All features are accessible at every tier, from $49 to $199/month, which is commendable. Their processing rates are lower too, at 2.75-2.9%, saving you $60-75/month on $10K processing. For small gyms, their $49/month plan proves cost-effective compared to our $29/month Starter plan with higher processing fees.
What ManageMemberships Does Better
Our door access control is native and billing-tied, priced at $89/month. GymDesk's $100/month smart lock add-on was an afterthought. We include a branded mobile app in our Core package, which GymDesk lacks. Our CRM with email/SMS campaigns features automated triggers—a step beyond GymDesk's basic tools. We also include digital waivers with e-signature, a native POS system for $59/month, and direct support from me, the founder. GymDesk's support has reportedly declined post-acquisition.
The PE Elephant in the Room
GymDesk's acquisition by private equity is telling. Typically, this means cutting the dev team, raising prices, and diminishing support—seen with platforms like Zen Planner and EZFacility. Users report GymDesk's app logs out weekly and hidden charges are creeping in. This doesn't make GymDesk bad today, but if you're choosing a platform for the long haul, ownership matters. ManageMemberships remains bootstrapped, with no investors or board pressures.
The Processing Fee Comparison (Honest Math)
GymDesk charges 2.75-2.9% + $0.25-0.30 per transaction, while ManageMemberships Core is 3.5% all-inclusive. For $10K processing, GymDesk costs ~$315/month, saving ~$35 against our $350/month. Yet, our rate includes CRM, email/SMS, a branded app, and waivers. Adding these to GymDesk could close or reverse the cost gap. If processing cost is paramount, GymDesk is cheaper. But consider the total ownership cost, including feature extras.
Door Access — The Real Differentiator
Here's where we differ most. GymDesk's $100/month smart lock integration works but is bolted on. Our $89/month native door access ties billing status to door control in real-time. Even if the internet goes down, our system operates through cached data. For those not needing 24/7 access, this difference is moot. But for unmanned access, it’s crucial at 2 AM when something breaks.
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | GymDesk | ManageMemberships |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $49/mo | Free / $29/mo |
| Unlimited members | $199/mo | $99/mo |
| Belt/rank tracking | ✓ Built-in | Coming soon |
| Door access | $100/mo add-on | $89/mo native |
| Billing → door sync | ✓ | ✓ Real-time |
| Branded mobile app | ✗ | ✓ Included (Core) |
| CRM + email/SMS | Basic | ✓ Full |
| Digital waivers | ✓ | ✓ |
| POS | Via Clover | $59/mo native |
| Processing rate | 2.75-2.9% | 3.5% all-in |
| Contracts | Month-to-month | Month-to-month |
| Ownership | Private equity | Bootstrapped |
Who Should Pick GymDesk
- Traditional martial arts schools where belt tracking is mission-critical
- Small gyms under 50 members where the $49/mo tier makes sense
- Gyms that are fully staffed during all open hours (no 24/7 unmanned access needed)
- Owners who prioritize lowest possible processing rate over feature breadth
Who Should Pick ManageMemberships
- 24/7 gyms or gyms with off-hours open mat / open gym
- MMA and BJJ academies that need door access tied to billing
- Gyms that want a branded mobile app without paying $97/mo extra
- Owners who want CRM and marketing tools built in rather than bolted on
- Anyone concerned about the PE acquisition trajectory at GymDesk
Bottom Line
Both platforms have their strengths. GymDesk's belt tracking is unmatched if that's your primary need. ManageMemberships shines with door access integration and a comprehensive feature set that supports 24/7 operations. One of our first customers moved from GymDesk specifically for this feature. Migration was smooth and trouble-free.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs. GymDesk offers trials, and ManageMemberships has a free tier. Test them out, see what fits, and make an informed decision based on your gym's requirements.
Smarter Billing, Better Control, Stronger Tools
Explore calendar billing, subscription management, automated door scheduling, digital waivers, reporting dashboards, and full member portal customization built specifically for gym and studio operators.
